Image by Lyn Millett via Flickr
Google has really stepped in it with the launch of their latest product, Buzz. Here's their blog announcement about it. They appear to still be trying to make a splash in the social networking space, and apparently wanted to avoid some of the problems that plagued them with Google Wave. In particular, one of the complaints about Wave was that you would log in, and there'd be no one to "wave" with. So this time, for the new product, Google decided to seed each person's contact list based on people they email with from their Gmail accounts. Umm, bad idea. And, to add to the annoyance, it was hard to understand how to turn this off. And it was all turned on automatically without so much as a "by your leave." Lawyers' and journalists' frequently-emailed contacts were exposed. Abusive ex-spouses gained accesses to contact lists. Basically, a full-blown privacy nightmare.
Business Insider, before some of the fixes that Google has deployed said:
A Google spokesperson tells us the followers lists are public by default so that people can quickly find new people to follow. Obviously, that's a good thing for Google, which is hoping to get as many people using Google Buzz as soon as possible. It's also meant to be helpful for users. And for those who are unconcerned with telling the world who they email most, it is. But for everyone else, it's terrible.MSNBC walked through some of the privacy issues and offered suggestions for how to adjust some of the defaults:
It gets to a deeper problem with Google Buzz: It's built on email, which is a very different Internet application than a social network.